Question:
In your opinion what is the worst F1 team ever?
Insert Name Here
2010-06-10 08:00:02 UTC
In your opinion what is the worst F1 team ever?
Twelve answers:
rosbif
2010-06-10 10:38:07 UTC
There are dozens of truly awful teams to choose from. If we exclude amateur entries intended to take part in their home GP only, and also teams which didn't build their own cars, then some of the worst ones to have started a race are:



1950s: Plenty of amateur efforts, but Alta stands out for the Irishman Joe Kelly actually managing to be unclassified in successive British GPs, 13 laps behind in 1950 and 15 laps down in 1951...



1960s: The stand-out worst team for me is A-T-S (1963-64). The car failed to qualify more times than it started, and the engine could only be removed from the chassis by using a hacksaw. Never qualified in the top 10, never scored a point.



1970s: A hard choice. But I'd go for Merzario (1978-80). Failed to qualify twice as often as it started, and never higher than 20th. Not one single race finish. The cars were bulky, ugly things which never had the basic speed to develop further.



1980s: Another decade with a lot of choice. Despite the prescence of Eurobrun, I think Coloni (1987-89) has to be the worst. More often than not, the car failed to prequalify. Half the rest of the time, it failed to qualify. And on the rare occasions that it did race, it broke. One 8th place, where some very late retirements moved the car up several places, was the highlight.



1990s: There were a few weak teams at the start of the decade, but nothing (not even the antiquated Forti) was as bad as the Andrea Moda (1992). Failure to pay the entry fee. Not having the cars ready. Drivers not having a superlicence. Forgetting about scrutineering. There were many way in which Andrea Moda contrived to make their slow car even less competitive. The car qualified just once, 26th and last at Monaco, and retired from last place when the engine broke.



2000s: The quality of teams has increased in recent times. Only HRT really qualifies for the worst team list, and even then they wouldn't have been THAT bad in past times.





Of course, for me there is only one contender if we include the teams that never even managed to qualify. Life entered just 14 races, but failed to even get out of prequalifying once. Gary Brabham made his bid for the worst qualifying performance in history: 143% of the pole time in Phoenix. He was replaced by the veteran Giacomelli, who had no greater success.





EDIT

@thatguywiththecodes

Yes, THAT Lola was terrible, but as a constructor their history is successful compared to the other cars listed here, with a pole position and 3 podiums to their credit.

@cube

The overall Minardi record may not be spectacular, but they did have a period in the late 1980s/early 1990s when it looked like they had got the hang of F1. In late 1989 Minardi stopped being a joke - I remember when Martini qualified 5th at Estoril and shocked the whole of F1. He then worked further miracles in Spain and Australia, and carried that form into 1990 - second on the grid in Phoenix - staying in the upper midfield for another 4 years. Minardi were crippled by the same thing that did for Pacific and Simtek among others: the huge changes in safety rules after Imola 1994 brought with them a huge financial burden, and for small teams the continual rule changes were simply too much. That Minardi survived at all is worth praising.
anonymous
2016-04-15 04:52:39 UTC
First, a question: Why do you ask for the worst ever, then limit it to the 1990s and 2000s? That's cutting out four decades worth. And almost everyone here has glossed right over the Life team. The chassis was probably only tied for the worst, but that infamous W12 engine usually blew up before the end of the one hour pre-qualifying session. And the drivers felt that even when running it was only developing about 300 bhp. But I still wish that I could see a diagram of it. And then there was the fact that the engine cover had trouble fitting over the engine, and other parts of the bodywork cracked because the chassis flexed too much, and the team couldn't afford new body pieces ...
Ivor
2010-06-10 12:36:57 UTC
I'd say the worst team is Minardi.



There have been several slower, worse teams over the years but they survived maybe 2-3 years tops.



Minardi survived for 345 races. Their first race was in 1985, their last in 2005.

Now, out of 345 races, they had no wins. They scored just 38 points in 20 years! Terrible.



In their first 3 years they only finished 10 times. That's 65 retirements in 3 seasons. They retired more than 200 times.



They never had a podium. Their best result was 4th. Their best championship result was 7th in the constructors. That was with 6 points.



They were a truly terrible team. I'm surprised the survived so long.



I can't go with USF1 because they didn't even make a car. They were barely a team. At least pick one that had a working car. (or one that started up at the least)
John A.
2010-06-12 23:02:05 UTC
I go with Rosbif's answer, it is well written.



As for USF1, they failed to even show up, so they should not be counted.



I can't understand why the Americans can't put anything together with all the knowledge there is here. When looking at the grid, I am almost ashamed to be an American. Why can't Americans compete with the rest of the world? Why should we always have our own world series in every sport instead of taking part in the world championship or world cup?
Will
2010-06-10 22:38:52 UTC
My picks would be either the Maki team of 1974-76, or Life Racing in 1990. Neither one of them were able to keep their welds from breaking, or make the body panels fit.



Although I would love to see a diagram of Life's W12 engine someday.
Lewis Hamilton's No1 Fan
2010-06-12 04:11:53 UTC
I don't think that USF1 as they did not even make it into F1. There have been loads of rubbish teams and i think rosbif has said them all.
Null Point
2010-06-11 07:34:40 UTC
the "myearthdreams" f1 team - sorry, I don't want to remember the exact name of the team
Angel H
2010-06-10 08:16:34 UTC
I'd say USF1, but then again they never really got to be an F1 team anyway.....
Thatguywiththecodes
2010-06-10 15:47:06 UTC
Mastercard Lola - Did not qualify for it's only GP, and gave up after that! Really messed up team.



Apparently they were going to enter in 1998 but Mastercard hurried them up. Sheesh!
gromit801
2010-06-10 15:37:04 UTC
I gotta go with Rosbif on this one.



USF1 wasn't a team. Just a factory that couldn't produce a product.
anonymous
2010-06-11 10:17:53 UTC
USF1 = EPIC FAIL.
anonymous
2010-06-10 14:53:28 UTC
USF1, god that was a disgrace.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...